Alright Zoo Freaks, the Zoo Crew just dropped the needle on a real gem from the late eighties Sunset Strip scene, and if you are hearing this one for the first time you are in for a treat. Shark Island's "Why Should I Believe" off the 1989 album Law of the Order is that rare power ballad that never slides into syrup or formula. Written by vocalist Richard Black and guitarist Spencer Sercombe, the track sits right in the middle of a record that fans still call a buried treasure. The band had already been grinding the Hollywood clubs for years by the time Epic Records finally put it out, and the song captures the weary edge of a group that had watched plenty of lesser outfits get the big push while they kept packing Gazzarri's night after night.
Richard Black has talked in interviews about how the whole Law of the Order session never quite bottled the fire the band brought to the stage. He once said the group was always a live act first, and comparing the studio versions to what they did at the Whisky felt unfair. They even recorded a full multi-track live show at the Whisky on Bastille Day in 1989 and Black lobbied hard to make that the debut release instead. The label wanted a polished studio album, so the live set stayed a radio promo. That same restless spirit runs through "Why Should I Believe." The lyrics open with a midnight drive, streetlights guiding someone who has decided there is nothing left in the old town worth staying for. Black sings about leaving it all behind, burning the bridges, and refusing to be molded into someone else's version of success. Fans who stuck with the band through the lean years often point to those lines as the sound of a man who had already seen the casting-couch side of the music business and chosen not to play along.
The album itself arrived with high hopes and almost no support. Epic had the single "Paris Calling" with a flashy video, plus two tracks that landed on the Bill & Ted's Excellent Adventure soundtrack, yet sales stayed modest and the promotion dried up fast. Critics and later fans still single out "Why Should I Believe" as one of the record's strongest moments, a tender ballad that keeps its grit. Black's vocal range stretches from the gritty verses into a soaring chorus without ever losing the edge that made Shark Island stand out from the pure glam pack. Sercombe's guitar work underneath is classic late-eighties melodic metal, big but never cluttered, the kind of playing that filled rooms on the Strip when the band was still called Sharks and sharing bills with Mötley Crüe and Quiet Riot.
That brings us to how the whole thing started. Back in 1979 a couple of high-school friends in the Los Angeles area decided to form a band. Rick Czerny, who would later take the name Richard Black, and Spencer Sercombe had been playing together and writing originals. They called themselves Sharks and cut an independent album called Altar Ego in 1982. Sercombe was already working at B.C. Rich guitars and helped shape the Warlock model that became a staple of the metal scene. The early lineup practiced in a home studio lined with Mickey's Big Mouth bottles, which inspired the shark-jaw logo they still use. By the mid-eighties they had changed the name to Shark Island, become the house band at Gazzarri's on the Sunset Strip, and built a reputation for high-energy shows that other singers paid attention to. Black has been open about the fact that Axl Rose studied his stage moves on old videotapes before Guns N' Roses took off. Bill Gazzarri even helped produce a cover of "New York, New York" that ended up on their 1986 independent release S'cool Buss.
From there it was the usual Hollywood grind: development deals, lineup changes, and the long wait for a major label. When Epic finally signed them, Black and Sercombe were still writing the songs that reflected the years of club work and the frustration of watching the industry pick winners for reasons that had little to do with the music. "Why Should I Believe" is one of those songs. The promise in the chorus, that the singer will be the judge of what is right for himself, lines up with things Black has said in later interviews about staying idealistic when easier paths were offered. He has described the business as full of corruption and desperation once the slots for big deals got scarce, and he chose not to play those games.
After Law of the Order the band scattered. Black joined the short-lived supergroup Contraband with Michael Schenker and members of L.A. Guns and Ratt. Sercombe worked with Schenker, Riverdogs, and others before eventually moving to Germany. The album found a second life years later when the French label Bad Reputation reissued it with live cuts and the soundtrack tracks. Fans who had worn out their original cassettes finally got a proper CD, and the cult following kept growing. Black has said in more recent talks that his dreams were huge when the band started, houses on both coasts and all the rest, but he is content with the legacy and the people who still connect with the songs. That connection is exactly what you hear when the Zoo Crew spins "Why Should I Believe" for the Zoo Freaks listening in from all over the map. The track still feels honest, still cuts through the gloss, and still sounds like the work of a band that earned every note the hard way on the Strip.
If you want to dig deeper into the history and catch up on what the current lineup has been doing, head over to the official Shark Island site at sharkislandmusic.com. You can also follow them on Facebook, Instagram, and X. And of course keep it locked right here on THE ZOO where the Zoo Crew keeps the deep cuts spinning for all you Zoo Freaks. That is the real Law of the Order around these parts.